Brighton Magazine

The Brighton Magazine

Selected Brighton Magazine Article

Wednesday 23 May 2012

Philharmonia Orchestra @ Brighton Festival: Powerful All-Russian Programme Proved Great Art Wins Out

All good journalists know that a review should be short, not a history lesson, not too academic and certainly not full of quotes from the programme. Also they should not pre-judge what will be the best single item from a festival that has not yet finished.

Guess what? I am about to smash those rules apart, but stick with me - this will be interesting. Oh, and it’s the best thing at the Festival this year.

This is a review of the Philharmonia Orchestra’s performance of Shostakovich’s Symphony no. 13 in B flat minor op.113, Babi Yar and Sergey Prokofiev’s Piano Concerto no.3 in C major op 26.

Suffice to say that pianist Nobuyuki Tsujii was a wonder. The Concerto no.3 is famously very hard to play and requires a lot of skill to perform, Nobuyuki held the audience in the palm of his hand.

The Philharmonia Orchestra are a great orchestra and gave him the best possible support alongside the talents of the former pianist and now conductor Vladimir Ashkenazy.

For the Shostakovich symphony, the Brighton Festival Chorus once again excelled themselves, singing in Russian with a power and precision that one expects of the great.

Sergei Aleksashkin was an incredible solo vocalist, again with a power to command the attention of an audience rapt in this incredible performance.

The Dome Concert Hall was just about sold out, so who says great art does not sell seats? Who says people are so stupid they can only handle the works of Simon Cowell? Not me folks.

Great art will always win through and Symphony no.13 is one of the most moving and powerful works you will ever witness.

From the Programme notes by James M Keller:

“‘Yesterday the Thirteenth Symphony by Shostakovich was performed’. If you had been a Russian reading Pravda, your state sanctioned newspaper, on 19th December, 1962, that is the sum total of what you would have learned about the premiere of one of the most heroic cultural moments produced in the second half of the twentieth century. You would not have read about the cloak and dagger manoeuvres that tried to keep the performance itself from taking place, nor would you have read  about the tumultuous applause that interrupted the piece at the end of the first movement.

…Symphony no.13 derived from an event on Soviet History…one that nobody wanted to talk about; The Nazis 1941 massacre of civilians, most of whom were Jewish, in the Baba Yar ravine in the north west outskirts of Kiev (in the Ukraine).

On the 29
th and 30th of September they marched every Jew they could round up to the Babi Yar ravine and…shot them at the edge of the cliff in groups of ten. According to the official Nazi count the execution toll of those two days amounted to 33,771…the majority of Ukrainians in the area proved enthusiastic, lending assistance to the occupying enemy. In the weeks that followed the Ukrainians turned over many thousands of Jews, as well as Gypsies psychiatric patients and other targets of Nazi eradication.“

Fourteen Jewish men escaped a working party in 1943 that was detailed with burning the rotting bodies to hide this terrible crime.

They told the world about what happened. But the Soviet authorities wanted to keep the matter quiet less it blur the heroism of the Great Patriotic War

This story came to the notice of Yevgeny Yevtushenko a dissident Soviet poet, who wrote his poem Baba Yar, it was then set to music by Shostakovich as the Symphony no.13.

This was a brave move.

The poem Babi Yar opens with the words:

“There is no memorial above Babi Yar.
The Steep ravine is like coarse Tombstone.
I’m Frightened,
I feel as old today,
as the Jewish race itself.
I feel now that I am a Jew.”

It goes on:

“I am behind bars, I am encircled,
persecuted, spat on, slandered,
and fine ladies with lace frills
squeal and poke their parasols in my face”

But why would these two men, poet and composer, identify so closely with this tragedy?

It seems to me that there are other factors at play concerning the state of the nation that the two men lived in.

Both had been oppressed by the Soviet system, Shostakovich was in constant fear of execution for many years under Stalin’s rule.

It seems that a sense of identification with the persecuted is at play here, this is empathy and not sympathy.

“I feel as though I am slowly turning grey.
And I become a long soundless scream,
above the thousands and thousands buried here,
I am each old man who was shot here,
I am each child who was shot here
Let the ‘International’ thunder out
When the last anti-semite on the earth
Has finally been buried.”

And later he talks of a state where:

“Fears slithered everywhere, like shadows,
penetrating every floor…
when we should have kept silent - they taught us to scream,
and to keep silent – when we should have screamed…
the secret fear of a knock at the door.”

Later he argues that men who choose to hide the truth to further their careers at the time and keep in with the powers that be will be doomed to obscurity and become objects of hate. Instead it is those who stand up for truth who have a true ‘career’.

Is there really anyone left who says that this is not a great and under performed work of art?


by: Howard Young (Arts Editor)


There are artists who are independent in the music industry sense, and artists who are independent in mind, spirit and the sheer bloody-mindedness with which they've made something of themselves. Nell Bryden fits both descriptions, and has the stories to prove it.
It was a sorely belated recognition for one of the most beautiful voices of the 21st century, matched by a songwriting and lyrical prowess that conveyed every atom of pain, fear and endurance that has defined John Grant's life so far, not just with a striking level of self-awareness but the most life-affirming streak of dark and scabrous humour too.
Sarah Evans from Brighton has launched a Crowdfunder campaign to raise £2,500 for breast cancer awareness charity, CoppaFeel!.
My Baby was born in the small hours of a red moonlit night in Amsterdam in 2012. Brother and sister Joost and Cato van Dijck fused their futures and blended their souls with accomplished slide and blues guitar player Daniel de Vries.
Brighton's Martlets Hospice is urging men across the City to sign up and take part in a thirteen mile sponsored walk along the Sussex coast. later this month.
Brighton Digital Festival, the UK's largest celebration of digital culture, came to a close following a record-breaking fifth year. 
Noel Fielding, best known for playing Vince Noir in The Mighty Boosh, is proud to have retained his child-like view of the world.
The first ever trans needs assessment in Brighton and Hove has found the city is trans-friendly but that discrimination, abuse and isolation is still a problem.
Brighton cyclist Peter Colmer battled hills, saddle sores and blisters to raise just under £2,000 for the YMCA DownsLink Group. 
Martlets Hospice have announced their Top Secret Art Project - an exciting exhibition and auction of original A5 sized art produced by celebrities, professional and amateur artists.
Teams from BBC Radio 3’s Live in Concert and Early Music Show will be in Brighton this autumn to record three concerts taking place as part of Brighton Early Music Festival, for broadcast in November.
A tonne of clothing donated by Cancer Research UK arrives at Brighton Open Market for three days of free public events and workshops around clothing sustainability.
Five-piece Eliza and the Bear unveil new single Lion's Heart and announce the release of their eponymously-titled debut album, as well as a forthcoming date in Brighton.
Thirty years ago, photographer, Jamie Morgan with his friend and collaborator, Ray Petrishowed up at the offices of street culture magazine, The Face, with a new editorial.

Archive search

Search our archives for what's on and gone for the best of this city's theatre music comedy news and much more...

Latest Brighton Jobs

Sessional Life Model

Sessions usually run for either 2 hours, 3 hours or 5 hours and the poses are negotiated with the lecturer....
City College Brighton & Hove - Brighton
More details

Sessional Life Model

Sessions usually run for either 2 hours, 3 hours or 5 hours and the poses are negotiated with the lecturer....
City College Brighton & Hove, Brighton - Brighton
More details

Registry Assistant

The postholder will have particular responsibility for attendance which involves processing absence notifications and inputting onto the student record system...
Varndean College - Brighton
More details

BMW Bodyshop Panel Apprentice - Chandlers Brighton

Candidates who do not hold these qualifications are still eligible to apply, as they can sit Functional Skills Level 2 in these subjects throughout their...
BMW Group Academy - Brighton
More details
Organising a conference or event in Brighton?
See our Brighton Conference section.
Brighton web design by ...ntd